Debut cover: Her Dark Virtue- Which do you choose?

I hope everyone is doing well and staying safe. Did anyone watch the latest (and final) episode of Supernatural? I know quite a bit of people have mixed view of things, myself included, but what we all can agree on Covid has been a real nasty sucker. On top of the amount of cases, deaths of loved ones, the game and tv/movie industry has suffered as well. It's going to take some time, but we can fight through this if we stand together. 

And speaking of standing together, fighting in the darkness. I am excited to say that BOOK TWO of 'Her Dark Virtue' is complete and will be with my editor come December. That also, said, I have not one, but two, covers. I won't get too much into it, but I wanted to vamp up the Paragons of Justice Series with new covers, new summaries, (new artwork? Wait and see ). But now, I am on the fence. I have had a few opinions but they were both 50/50. 

On the one hand, the original book two I had (like for Book one of Her Dark Sins) was supposed to represent a comic/manga style as that's what the series is based on. So I am asking you, dear folks out there, if you have a moment to spare--Which do you prefer?